Patrick Wolf
Yoga Studio
Wind in the wires, calm in your core.
Find Your Magic Position
Serving a bit of the Midwest.
Sufjan Stevens
50 States Moving Co.
Get A Free Estimate
Message Board
Exhaust - Enregistreur
1 replies · 2026-03-20
Album Art Challenge #073: 2007 Releases
1 replies · 2026-03-16
Album Art Challenge #053: Layla
1 replies · 2026-03-16
Album Art Challenge #034: Piano Men
1 replies · 2026-03-16
Bjork- Medulla. Overrated?
This post is
?
YEARS OLD
calculating...

Having listened to the album about 20 times since buying it, I can't say I'm blown away. I'm reading too many reviews in which the critics praise Bjork's arrangements and technique at the expense of the songs, which are, with a few exceptions, non-descript and amelodic. It's a trend I've lamented since "Vespertine," the first time Ms. Gudmonsdottir's songwriting and vocal affectations started to irritate the hell out of me.

In other words, folks, it's the Radiohead Syndrome again. We admire the artists' studio prowess, attack the Big Bad Industry for its conservatism, pour a glass of red wine, put on the album, and wonder whether the pain that gnaws away at our attention span is a result of boredom or that ham sandwich we ate for lunch. I mean, what the hell else are we supposed to make of "Where Is The Line" and "øoll Birtan"? We listen and think, "Why, how nice, how INNOVATIVE" and hit fast forward.

I certainly encourage Bjork to continue these hirstute experiments - with the caveat that she program some funk beats in b/w the Icelandic Vocal Choir, Robert Wyatt, et al. Arguably her most lasting work rests on that sequence of albums from "Debut" to "Homogenic"; on "Medulla" maybe "Triumph of the Heart" and "Oceania" and the lovely e.e. cummings-indebted "Sonnets" will join them.


By: Alfred Soto
Published on: September 13, 2004
 
Leave a Comment
 
Serving a bit of the Midwest.
Sufjan Stevens
50 States Moving Co.
Get A Free Estimate
Music Reviews
Movie Reviews
Features