scowl. A scintilla of tension, held or released. A rifle report. A kiss. Cinema is composed of privileged moments, born of pulp and transfigured as art. In Scenes, a writer will study one of these moments. The approach is up to the writer. They may analyze the scene from a technical standpoint, discuss the dramatic elements in play, or find personal correspondences. Enjoy.
In the calm cool of springtime dusk in a small Maine fishing town, a young couple rests intimately in a quiet backyard. The young man, Frank, college-aged, lies on his side, while his lover, Natalie, watches him expectantly as he builds a small fortress out of her children’s blocks. “You know,” she tells him, “I’ve been ignoring our difference in age, but if you keep playing with those blocks, I’m going to start to worry.”
Frank has heard this before, and, so enraptured in his work that he barely looks up, defends his manhood casually. A prospective grad student in architecture, he’s recreating the work of the architect Mack, who devised a family unit in which the children are housed on one side, the parents on the other, so that they all spill into a central area. “It’s brilliant,” he says almost breathlessly, before timidly looking up at his older girlfriend, worried he has bored her. Among the few to leave the sleepy costal town to attend college (his father is the town’s doctor), he might assume his explanation had swerved too theoretical for her, a woman who wed young, had two sons and is now in the thick of a trying, sometimes violent divorce.
Whatever the case, she smiles. Natalie has a wiser air about her than he realizes, an understanding that has come along with a rushed maturity Frank will never quite understand. To her, his innocence is both boyish and faintly erotic, a reminder of the youth she sacrificed long before she understood what she was giving up.
This scene, early in Todd Field’s 2001 masterwork In the Bedroom, is perhaps most indicative of the intimacy that makes the film one of the defining works of the past decade. A devastating, at times unbearably frank, deconstruction of familial tragedy, the film’s first third explores the young couple’s romance with underpinnings of menace just tenuous enough to slip under the radar. Frank (Nick Stahl) describes his relationship with Natalie (Marisa Tomei) as “a summer thing,” but his bond with at least one of her boys and his increasing indifference toward returning to school clearly suggest otherwise. His mother (Sissy Spacek) speaks her mind about the relationship, but is too tightly wound to admit she’s threatened by Natalie’s divorce, and his father (Tom Wilkinson) quietly challenges their sexual relationship, as if he has some unspoken stake in it.
Meanwhile, danger is brewing. Natalie’s ex-husband (a terrifying William Mapother) breaks into the family’s old home through the chimney, where Natalie finds him helping himself to dinner when she returns home from work. He shows up to a birthday party for his sons thrown by Frank’s parents just to show he can. Frank, of course, brushes off Natalie and his parents’ concern with shrugging arrogance. In retrospect, the scene seems dangerously naïve given what follows, but first-time director Field places the audience very much in the moment, photographing it with the invisible command of a career filmmaker.
The scene naturally extends into talk of the couple’s future. Natalie’s younger son, Jason, is still more inclined to her ex, but his older brother Duncan confides in Frank as if he were his father. After Frank suggests he put off school for a year to be with Natalie and her boys, she is grateful but incredulous. He comforts her the only way he possibly could: “You what Duncan said to me the other day? He said, ‘Frank, I don’t think Jason really understands girls.’ ” Then the key line: “If this is how he is now, we’re in trouble.” Natalie is no longer entranced with him. Despite the illusions Frank contrives for his own comfort and the occasional glimmer of hope in her eyes, she knows their relationship can’t last beyond the summer, and more importantly that his parents would consider it a personal betrayal if it did.
But she is in love, and Frank at the very least thinks he is. The scene is ultimately an elegy to their romance that Field renders with a fond, mournful eye. The impending tragedy wouldn’t pack nearly such a punch if not for the primal beauty of these early scenes. Invasive headlights and a haunting choral soundtrack end the scene as Natalie’s ex-husband pulls into the driveway before them, and in one of its few sparing touches, the camera cuts away, unwilling to taint the lovers’ moment.
|
By: Jeffrey Bloomer Published on: 2006-10-30 Comments (0) |
Leave a Comment
